Rush and Valens go to Valens’s old sergeant, who had arrested Matt and Blaine, to see if he can help. They grab a carpet fiber to match to the one found in the print. She allows Henry to come over and use her because she’s too scared to try and stop him.
Rush, Valens, and Royal interview the girlfriend, Janice. More and more evidence points to him being the culprit. At the precinct, Sam Royal of the Delaware State Police arrives to help and narrows down the suspect list to Henry Floyd who also has the same shoe size print that was found next to Matt’s body. When asked about that night, Blaine says they were celebrating a possible business venture that could have made them millionaires. They question Blaine and find that he and Matt robbed the food mart for a small business startup selling candy bars. Matt was the ideal son for the next three years while Blaine stayed in Atlantic City. His parents said that after he went through lock up, he straightened himself out.
When Rush brings up the food mart incident, his parents explain that he went through a rough period of stealing. They said Matt was working as an investor during the day then taking classes at Drexel University at night. She sits on the steps, listening as they talk to Matt’s parents. Rush and Valens visit Matt’s house and meet his younger sister Katy. They also find a note stating that Matt and his cousin, Blaine, robbed a food mart on probation.
They scour the files and theorize the possibility of a serial killer. One happened in Delaware, one in New Jersey, and one in Pennsylvania. Stillman hands them a file of what appears to be a third in a string of similar murders: young white male, in the woods, shot in the chest with a. In the present day, Lily and Scotty come into work, joking what they would do if they won the lottery. Later he's found dead in the woods, buried under some leaves. A young man flirts with a blackjack dealer as he piles up his winnings. The recent murder of a young, male hitchhiker in Delaware sheds new light on the similar murder of a young man near Philadelphia in 1997, leading detectives to suspect the two murders may have been committed by the same person.